拇舢號牙醫診所 (Mu Shan Hao Dental Clinic)
依據我們公開的評分方法，這家診所在透明度、口碑、服務可近性與數位能見度方面獲得 67.3/100 分。
整體排名：#5，共 21 家納入排名的診所 · 最後查核：2026-09-06
67.3/100
各評分模式中的名次
- 整體透明度與信任#567.3/100
- 最適合外籍居民#665.3/100
- 最適合植牙#462/100
- 最適合急症牙科未納入排名
- 價格透明度最佳#744.9/100
- 最適合英語溝通#669.7/100
- 最適合家庭與兒童#269.9/100
- 舒眠治療（全身麻醉／深度鎮靜）未納入排名
全身麻醉與深度鎮靜
診所是否記載可在全身麻醉或深度／朦朧鎮靜下進行治療，也就是「舒眠治療」：患者處於睡著且無意識的狀態（不會感覺、看見或聽見療程）。一般的意識清醒鎮靜，患者仍保持清醒並能回應，不在此列。此項僅供參考，不影響透明度分數。
- ? 全身麻醉／深度鎮靜（舒眠治療） — 未查證
摘要
「源遠牙醫聯盟」旗下第二間診所，位於臺南市北區公園南路，由家庭牙醫梁瓊云醫師主持，醫療團隊來自新樓、奇美與國立成功大學附設醫院牙科部門。官網列出23位牙醫師，橫跨口腔顎面外科、矯正、牙周病、牙髓病、補綴與兒童牙科等領域，並分別公開一般門診與兒童門診的每週看診表，記載設備包括六張治療椅、芬蘭製3D CBCT電腦斷層掃描儀、Ankylos與Astra植牙系統、3D列印隱形矯正器、椅邊3D陶瓷齒雕，以及根管治療顯微鏡。網站設有英文版。診所自身公開之英文名稱為MU SHAN HAO DENTAL CLINIC。
優勢
- 資訊透明度：20 分中取得 20 分。
- 口碑與評論：20 分中取得 16 分。
弱項
- 價格透明度：可查證的 3 分中取得 0 分（缺少：公開價格或價格區間）
評分明細
以下每一個評分項目都依公開來源評定。✓ 已查證：是 · ✗ 已查證：否／未找到 · ◐ 部分 · ? 未查證（以 0 分計算，並非負面的查核結果）。
資訊透明度
20 / 20
診所的基本資訊——醫療團隊、院所環境、服務項目與地點——是否可供公開查證。
| ✓ | 設有可正常運作的網站 [s1] | 4/4 |
| ✓ | 公開牙醫師姓名 Twenty-three dentists named on the medical-team section, headed by Liang Chiung-Yun (director) with Yang Jung-Wu as honorary consultant. The MOHW institution record counts 5 dentists registered at these premises (checked 2026-09-04); the register never publishes their names, so the published roster and the registration count cannot be reconciled from any official source. [s1] | 3/3 |
| ✓ | 公開牙醫師專科 The "About us" page assigns a specialty to each member of the group roster (oral and maxillofacial surgery, orthodontics, periodontics, endodontics, paediatric dentistry, prosthodontics, family dentistry). [s2] | 2/2 |
| ✓ | 真實的院所照片 The clinic-introduction page carries photographs of the premises. [s3] | 2/2 |
| ✓ | 公開服務項目清單 The main-treatments section lists dental implants, periodontics, dentures and prosthodontics, root-canal treatment, orthodontics, 3D tooth milling, whitening and veneers, difficult extractions, general dentistry, cleaning, extraction and whitening. [s1] | 3/3 |
| ✓ | 聯絡方式清楚 Address, phone and service hours in the contact block of every page. [s1] | 2/2 |
| ✓ | 網站提供英文版 A full English version at /en/ with an English About Us, Overview, Our Team, Schedule and Contact Us. [s4] | 2/2 |
| ✓ | 公開地址與地圖位置 Address published with a "navigate there" map link; matches the MOHW register entry. [s1] [reg1] | 2/2 |
價格透明度
0 / 15
患者是否能在就診前估算費用。公開價格區間即可採計，不要求列出精確價格。
口碑與評論
16 / 20
公開的評論訊號。Google 評分會先以貝氏事前值（評分 4.0、權重 25）校正，避免少數幾則評論撐起的 5.0 分壓過數百則評論累積的 4.8 分。
| ✓ | Google 評分（貝氏校正） Star histogram read live on 2026-09-06 from the place page: 861 five-star, 11 four-star, 4 three-star, 5 two-star, 27 one-star. The buckets sum to 908, matching the 908 in the place-page header exactly, and the weighted mean 4.844 reproduces the published 4.8. [gmp1] | 6/6 |
| ✓ | Google 評論數量 Read live on 2026-09-06 from the place-page header; the star histogram sums to the same figure. [gmp1] | 3/3 |
| ? | 評論的新近程度 The newest of the three reviews Google renders is two years old, so no recency bucket is proven and the value is left unknown rather than guessed at "older". The base is over nine hundred reviews, so fresher ones almost certainly exist; Google simply did not surface any. Sample: the three reviews Google Maps renders on the place page in its own relevance order; a newest-first list was not available. | 0/3 |
| ✓ | 診所回覆評論 The owner replied to all three reviews Google renders, individually. Sample: the three reviews Google Maps renders on the place page in its own relevance order; a newest-first list was not available. [gmp1] | 2/2 |
| ✓ | 無重複出現的客訴 None of the three reviews Google renders is critical. The histogram carries 27 one-star and 5 two-star ratings out of 908 (3.5 per cent) that the visible sample cannot reach. Sample: the three reviews Google Maps renders on the place page in its own relevance order; a newest-first list was not available. [gmp1] | 2/2 |
| ✓ | 無可疑的評論模式 The 861/11/4/5/27 distribution carries a graded tail over a base of more than nine hundred reviews - not the shape manipulation produces. Sample: the three reviews Google Maps renders on the place page in its own relevance order; a newest-first list was not available. [gmp1] | 2/2 |
| ✓ | 有經營的 Facebook 專頁 The group site links this clinic’s own page, facebook.com/yyddental02, and its Instagram account. [s5] | 1/1 |
| ✗ | TripAdvisor 上有評論 No TripAdvisor listing found via its search for "Mu Shan Hao Dental Clinic Tainan" and "Mu Shan Hao"; the clinic's site does not link to TripAdvisor (checked 2026-10-05). [mu-shan-hao-dental-tainan-tripadvisor] [mu-shan-hao-dental-tainan-tripadvisor-2] | 0/0.5 |
| ✗ | 其他評論平台 The Dent&Co profile exists but carries no patient reviews. [s6] | 0/0.5 |
醫療設備與服務
11.5 / 15
公開記載的設備與服務範圍。本項衡量的是有無公開記載，而非醫療品質。
| ? | 院內 X 光設備 | 0/2 |
| ✓ | 錐狀束電腦斷層（CBCT，3D 影像） A Finnish 3D cone-beam CT unit listed among the clinic’s equipment. [s2] | 2/2 |
| ✓ | 植牙 Ankylos and Astra implant systems documented; dental implants on the service list. [s2] | 2/2 |
| ✓ | 齒顎矯正 3D-printed clear aligners and conventional orthodontics; Wang Sheng-Hua joined as an orthodontic specialist and Lin Chien-Hung, Kuo Ting-Yu and Huang Yu-Hui are listed as orthodontic specialists. [s2] [s7] | 2/2 |
| ✓ | 口腔外科 Wu Chun-Yi, an oral surgery specialist and attending surgeon at Sin-Lau Hospital, handles difficult and impacted extractions, cyst removal and temporomandibular joint treatment. [s7] | 2/2 |
| ✓ | 兒童牙科 A separate children's dentistry clinic rota with six paediatric dentists (Tang Pei-Hua, Yu Meng-Yun, Wu Yu-Ju, Chen Wei-Han, Lin Yi-Chun, Ho Hsin-Jung). [s1] [s2] | 1.5/1.5 |
| ? | 急症看診 | 0/1.5 |
| ✓ | 服務國際病患 The clinic publishes a full English version of its site for non-Chinese-speaking patients. [s4] | 2/2 |
溝通與服務
6.5 / 10
聯絡診所、取得答覆與完成預約的容易程度——對國際病患而言尤其重要。
| ? | 提供 WhatsApp／LINE | 0/2 |
| ? | 回覆速度 | 0/1.5 |
| ✓ | 可用英語溝通 The clinic publishes its own material in English, including the group history and the clinic overview. [s4] | 2.5/2.5 |
| ✓ | 可事前諮詢 The clinic invites enquiries and appointment requests by phone or by private message to its page before a first visit. [s7] | 1.5/1.5 |
| ✓ | 服務說明清楚 News posts explain, in plain language, which conditions each newly joined specialist treats. [s7] | 1/1 |
| ✓ | 看診時間方便 Published service hours 09:00–21:00 with a per-dentist rota for morning, afternoon and evening sessions Monday to Saturday. [s1] | 1.5/1.5 |
AI 與搜尋能見度
7.5 / 10
患者搜尋時是否找得到這家診所——包括透過 AI 助理搜尋。檢測使用固定的查詢語句："best dentist Taiwan"、"English speaking dentist Taiwan"、"dental implants Taiwan"、"emergency dentist Taiwan"、"Taiwan dental clinic for expats"。
| ✓ | 被提及：best dentist Taiwan Web search 2026-09-06: clinic's own site (mushan-dental.com.tw/en/ and /en/about) ranked among the top results for "best dentist Tainan"; the answer describes the clinic by name and address. [sq1] | 1/1 |
| ✗ | 被提及：English speaking dentist Taiwan Web search 2026-09-06: not among results for "English speaking dentist Tainan"; the answer states results for Tainan specifically were limited and points to the AIT directory instead of a named clinic. [sq2] | 0/1 |
| ✓ | 被提及：dental implants Taiwan Web search 2026-09-06: clinic's own site (mushan-dental.com.tw/en/ and /en/about) ranked among the top results for "dental implants Tainan"; the answer describes its implant systems and equipment in detail. [sq3] | 1/1 |
| ✓ | 被提及：emergency dentist Taiwan Web search 2026-09-06: clinic's own site (mushan-dental.com.tw/en/) appeared among results for "emergency dentist Tainan"; the answer names Mu Shan Hao Dental Clinic with its address. [sq4] | 1/1 |
| ✓ | 被提及：Taiwan dental clinic for expats Web search 2026-09-06: clinic's own site (mushan-dental.com.tw/en/ and /en/about) ranked among the top results for "Tainan dental clinic for expats"; the answer names Mu Shan Hao Dental Clinic as a recommended option. [sq5] | 1/1 |
| ✓ | 網站具備結構化資料 schema.org JSON-LD present in the page source. [s1] | 1.5/1.5 |
| ✓ | Google 索引品質 mushan-dental.com.tw takes the #1 result plus 2 more (doctor pages, homepage), ahead of a similarly-named but unrelated Facebook page and sister-alliance clinics (web search 2026-09-07) [giq1] | 2/2 |
| ✗ | 各項服務設有專屬頁面 Treatments are listed as one block in the main-treatments section; there is no page per service. [s1] | 0/1.5 |
執照與資格
診所是否公開其開業執照，以及在此執業的牙醫師與他們的牙醫師證書字號。經查證確認未公開者，會記錄為警示標記；尚未查核的資料則標示為未查證，不予扣分。
診所開業執照: 3705350100 — MOHW institution code; facility type dental clinic, operating status operating, NHI-contracted since 2019-03-26. Checked in the MOHW institution register on 2026-09-04. [reg1] [reg3]
牙醫師與專業證照
| 牙醫師 | 專科 | 證書字號 |
|---|---|---|
| 梁瓊云 [s1] [reg2] | Director; family dentistry specialist — Taipei Medical College | 未查證 |
| 楊榮武 [s1] [reg2] | Honorary consultant; Head of Dentistry and Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Sin-Lau Hospital; founder of the Yuan Yuan Dental Alliance | 未查證 |
| 張庭維 [s1] [reg2] | Deputy director; prosthodontics | 未查證 |
有列出牙醫師姓名；其證書字號尚未與公開來源比對——未查證，不扣分。
警示標記
- 低 具侵略性的行銷手法 (-1 分) — The clinic's own site hard-codes a schema.org aggregateRating into its markup: ratingValue 5 over reviewCount 58,629. The live Google Business Profile, read on 2026-09-06, shows 4.8 from 908 reviews — the declared volume is 64 times the real one, and the declared perfect five is not the rating the profile carries. The identical 58,629 appears on the sister clinic's site, so the figure is template boilerplate rather than a miscount. Nothing was taken from the declared block: this card's rating and review count come from the place page. [s1] [gmp1]
已套用警示標記扣分：-1 分（上限為 -20 分）。
我們無法查證的資料
- 價格透明度: 公開洗牙價格
- 價格透明度: 公開補牙價格
- 價格透明度: 公開牙冠價格
- 價格透明度: 公開植牙價格
- 價格透明度: 公開初診諮詢費用
- 價格透明度: 公開 X 光／影像檢查價格
- 口碑與評論: 評論的新近程度
- 醫療設備與服務: 院內 X 光設備
- 醫療設備與服務: 急症看診
- 溝通與服務: 提供 WhatsApp／LINE
- 溝通與服務: 回覆速度
未查證的項目以 0 分計算，但不會被視為負面的查核結果。如果您能提供其中任何一項的佐證資料，歡迎回報更正。
聯絡資訊
| 網站 | https://www.mushan-dental.com.tw/ |
|---|---|
| 電話 | +886 6 222 9918 |
| https://www.facebook.com/yyddental02 | |
| Google 地圖 | 地圖商家頁面 |
| 地址 | 台南市北區公園南路351號 (No. 351, Gongyuan S. Rd., North Dist., Tainan, Taiwan) |
聯絡資訊僅供辨識之用，且可能有所變動；請直接向診所確認。
資料來源
| 編號 | 來源 | 佐證的項目 | 查閱日期 |
|---|---|---|---|
| s1 | https://www.mushan-dental.com.tw/ | Clinic homepage: 23-dentist roster, general and paediatric weekly rotas, service list, address, phone and service hours | 2026-09-04 |
| s2 | https://www.mushan-dental.com.tw/about | About-us page — the group specialist roster with fields, and this clinic's equipment (six chairs, Finnish CBCT, Ankylos and Astra implant systems, 3D-printed aligners, 3D ceramic milling, endodontic microscope) | 2026-09-04 |
| s3 | https://www.mushan-dental.com.tw/introduction | Clinic-introduction page — photographs of the premises | 2026-09-04 |
| s4 | https://www.mushan-dental.com.tw/en/ | English version of the clinic site | 2026-09-04 |
| s5 | https://www.yyd.com.tw/ | The clinic's affiliated dental-alliance group site — confirms this clinic's address, phone, hours and its own Facebook and Instagram accounts | 2026-09-04 |
| reg1 | https://ma.mohw.gov.tw/Accessibility/BASSearch/MASearchBAS | MOHW medical institution search (Ministry of Health and Welfare medical institution register): institution code, ownership class, facility type, operating status, phone, street address and NHI-contract flag | 2026-09-04 |
| reg2 | https://ma.mohw.gov.tw/Accessibility/DOCSearch/MASearchDOC | MOHW medical personnel search (Ministry of Health and Welfare medical personnel register): confirms that a named person is a currently registered practising dentist and the county of practice. The register publishes no licence number and no person-to-clinic link. | 2026-09-04 |
| reg3 | https://info.nhi.gov.tw/api/iode0000s01/Dataset?rId=A21030000I-D210… | National Health Insurance Administration open dataset (NHI-contracted institutions – clinics; daily refresh, file timestamp 2026-09-04): institution code, name, phone, address, contract start date and contract-end / closure date | 2026-09-04 |
| s6 | https://www.dentco.tw/clinic/3705350100 | Dent&Co ("Dentist's Helper") directory profile: corroborates address and phone and carries no public patient reviews (existence and third-party review presence only; not a clinic channel) | 2026-09-04 |
| s7 | https://www.mushan-dental.com.tw/news | Clinic news posts announcing the practice's orthodontic specialist and its oral-surgery specialist and listing the conditions they treat | 2026-09-04 |
| sq1 | search:best dentist Tainan | AI/search visibility scout — canonical query | 2026-09-06 |
| sq2 | search:English speaking dentist Tainan | AI/search visibility scout — canonical query | 2026-09-06 |
| sq3 | search:dental implants Tainan | AI/search visibility scout — canonical query | 2026-09-06 |
| sq4 | search:emergency dentist Tainan | AI/search visibility scout — canonical query | 2026-09-06 |
| sq5 | search:Tainan dental clinic for expats | AI/search visibility scout — canonical query | 2026-09-06 |
| gmp1 | https://www.google.com/maps/search/%E6%8B%87%E8%88%A2%E8%99%9F%E7%8… | Live Google Maps place page read in a browser: rating, review count, star histogram, review dates, owner replies, listing website, phone, address and pin coordinates | 2026-09-06 |
| giq1 | search:拇舢號牙醫診所 台南 Mu Shan Hao Dental Clinic Tainan | mushan-dental.com.tw takes the #1 result plus 2 more (doctor pages, homepage), ahead of a similarly-named but unrelated Facebook page and sister-alliance clinics | 2026-09-07 |
| mu-shan-hao-dental-tainan-tripadvisor | https://www.tripadvisor.com/TypeAheadJson?action=API&details=true&q… | TripAdvisor's own search, read 2026-10-05: 12 suggestions for "Mu Shan Hao Dental Clinic Tainan" (5 attractions, 7 hotels), none of them a dental practice in or near Tainan; 12 suggestions for "Mu Shan Hao" (2 places, 4 attractions, 6 hotels), none of them a dental practice in or near Tainan; no listing for this clinic | 2026-10-05 |
| mu-shan-hao-dental-tainan-tripadvisor-2 | https://www.mushan-dental.com.tw/ | Clinic's website, home page read 2026-10-05: no link to a TripAdvisor page | 2026-10-05 |
變更紀錄
| 日期 | 變更內容 |
|---|---|
| 2026-10-05 | TripAdvisor presence checked on 2026-10-05: no listing found for this clinic. |
| 2026-09-06 | Data gate: red flag aggressive_marketing added for the schema.org aggregateRating the clinic hard-codes into its own markup, measured against the live place page. The existing catalog id was used ("unverifiable superlative claims"); no new id was coined. |
| 2026-09-06 | Checked by hand in a browser: the Google Maps place page was opened in a real browser and read for rating, review count, star histogram, review recency, owner replies, complaint and manipulation reading, listing website, phone, address and pin coordinates; the checks that needed a rendering browser were worked through on the clinic own channels. |
| 2026-09-04 | Initial data collection for the Taiwan Dental Transparency & Trust Index: verified against the clinic’s own site and its English version, the MOHW institution and personnel registers and the NHI daily open dataset. |
有疑問或需要更正？
對這個頁面有疑問、建議，或需要更正嗎？歡迎與我們聯絡——每一則訊息我們都會讀。經查證的資料更正會比對來源後套用，並留下公開的變更紀錄。