上鼎牙醫診所
依據我們公開的評分方法，這家診所在透明度、口碑、服務可近性與數位能見度方面獲得 51.1/100 分。
整體排名：#20，共 21 家納入排名的診所 · 最後查核：2026-09-06
51.1/100
各評分模式中的名次
- 整體透明度與信任#2051.1/100
- 最適合外籍居民#2047.5/100
- 最適合植牙#1947/100
- 最適合急症牙科未納入排名
- 價格透明度最佳#2035.5/100
- 最適合英語溝通未納入排名
- 最適合家庭與兒童未納入排名
- 舒眠治療（全身麻醉／深度鎮靜）未納入排名
全身麻醉與深度鎮靜
診所是否記載可在全身麻醉或深度／朦朧鎮靜下進行治療，也就是「舒眠治療」：患者處於睡著且無意識的狀態（不會感覺、看見或聽見療程）。一般的意識清醒鎮靜，患者仍保持清醒並能回應，不在此列。此項僅供參考，不影響透明度分數。
- ? 全身麻醉／深度鎮靜（舒眠治療） — 未查證
摘要
位於高雄市左營區華夏路、採預約制的牙醫診所，自2000年起為健保特約診所，由曾於美國密西根大學進修植牙與牙周病學的吳文鑫醫師主持。診所列出三位牙醫師之完整資歷，每週看診時段表標示各時段駐診醫師，設備頁面記載3D CBCT電腦斷層掃描儀、數位全景與側顱X光機、手術室內建X光機、手術顯微鏡、雷射與超音波骨刀等設備。診所公開之診療重點為牙齒保存、非手術性牙周治療、顯微根管治療與微創智齒拔除。診所除網域名稱外並未公開英文名稱，網址代稱採用不標聲調之漢語拼音（Shangding）。
優勢
- 資訊透明度：20 分中取得 18 分。
- 在公開來源中未發現警示標記。
弱項
- 價格透明度：可查證的 3 分中取得 0 分（缺少：公開價格或價格區間）
- AI 與搜尋能見度：可查證的 10 分中取得 1.5 分（缺少：被提及：best dentist Taiwan; 被提及：English speaking dentist Taiwan; 被提及：dental implants Taiwan; 被提及：emergency dentist Taiwan; 被提及：Taiwan dental clinic for expats; 網站具備結構化資料; google 索引品質）
評分明細
以下每一個評分項目都依公開來源評定。✓ 已查證：是 · ✗ 已查證：否／未找到 · ◐ 部分 · ? 未查證（以 0 分計算，並非負面的查核結果）。
資訊透明度
18 / 20
診所的基本資訊——醫療團隊、院所環境、服務項目與地點——是否可供公開查證。
| ✓ | 設有可正常運作的網站 [s1] | 4/4 |
| ✓ | 公開牙醫師姓名 Three dentists named on the dentist-team page: Wu Wen-Hsin (director), Lin Ming-Hsien, Kuo Li-Ju. The MOHW institution record counts 1 dentist registered at these premises (checked 2026-09-04); the register never publishes their names, so the published roster and the registration count cannot be reconciled from any official source. [s2] | 3/3 |
| ✓ | 公開牙醫師專科 Full credential lists, e.g. Wu Wen-Hsin — implant and periodontics specialty training at the University of Michigan (USA), implant specialist of the Taiwan implant dentistry society, Invisalign clear-aligner international specialist certification. [s2] | 2/2 |
| ✓ | 真實的院所照片 Photographs of the premises and treatment rooms across the homepage and case pages. [s1] | 2/2 |
| ✓ | 公開服務項目清單 The treatments section lists general NHI care, minimally invasive extraction, periodontal treatment, halitosis treatment, anterior aesthetics, microscopic root-canal treatment and removable dentures. [s4] | 3/3 |
| ✓ | 聯絡方式清楚 Consultation line, second mobile number and address in the header and footer of every page. [s1] | 2/2 |
| ✗ | 網站提供英文版 Traditional Chinese only. [s1] | 0/2 |
| ✓ | 公開地址與地圖位置 Address published site-wide with a Google Maps link; matches the MOHW register entry. [s1] [reg1] | 2/2 |
價格透明度
0 / 15
患者是否能在就診前估算費用。公開價格區間即可採計，不要求列出精確價格。
口碑與評論
12.5 / 20
公開的評論訊號。Google 評分會先以貝氏事前值（評分 4.0、權重 25）校正，避免少數幾則評論撐起的 5.0 分壓過數百則評論累積的 4.8 分。
| ◐ | Google 評分（貝氏校正） Star histogram read live on 2026-09-06 from the place page: 155 five-star, 4 four-star, 0 three-star, 2 two-star, 27 one-star. The buckets sum to 188, matching the 188 in the place-page header exactly, and the weighted mean 4.372 reproduces the published 4.4. [gmp1] | 4/6 |
| ◐ | Google 評論數量 Read live on 2026-09-06 from the place-page header; the star histogram sums to the same figure. [gmp1] | 2/3 |
| ✓ | 評論的新近程度 The newest review visible is 3 months old, which proves the within-3-months bucket and no better. Sample: the three reviews Google Maps renders on the place page in its own relevance order; a newest-first list was not available. [gmp1] | 3/3 |
| ? | 診所回覆評論 Owner replies appear only on older reviews (latest 2021-08-19); none of the 6 reviews from the last 12 months read carries one. [shangding-dental-kaohsiung-deepen-2] | 0/2 |
| ? | 無重複出現的客訴 1–2★ ratings are 30 of 189 (15.9 %), but the lowest-rated reviews read a mix (profit-driven implant care, a hurried visit with a registration fee, a filling the dentist could not finish, a prescription despite a recorded allergy), none shared by three. [shangding-dental-kaohsiung-deepen-2] | 0/2 |
| ✓ | 無可疑的評論模式 The 155/4/0/2/27 distribution is bimodal, which is the signature of a divided patient base rather than of manipulation. Sample: the three reviews Google Maps renders on the place page in its own relevance order; a newest-first list was not available. [gmp1] | 2/2 |
| ✓ | 有經營的 Facebook 專頁 The clinic links its own page, facebook.com/denttop. [s1] | 1/1 |
| ✗ | TripAdvisor 上有評論 No TripAdvisor listing found via its search for the clinic's name and a short form of it; the clinic's site does not link to TripAdvisor (checked 2026-10-05). [shangding-dental-kaohsiung-tripadvisor] [shangding-dental-kaohsiung-tripadvisor-2] | 0/0.5 |
| ✓ | 其他評論平台 Dent&Co profile carries several thousand public patient reviews. [s5] | 0.5/0.5 |
醫療設備與服務
10 / 15
公開記載的設備與服務範圍。本項衡量的是有無公開記載，而非醫療品質。
| ✓ | 院內 X 光設備 Full-mouth digital X-ray, orthodontic cephalometric X-ray and an X-ray unit inside the operating room, all on the professional-equipment page. [s3] | 2/2 |
| ✓ | 錐狀束電腦斷層（CBCT，3D 影像） 3D CT on the professional-equipment page. [s3] | 2/2 |
| ✓ | 植牙 A Japanese NSK implant motor on the equipment page and implant consultation as a bookable item on the clinic’s appointment form. [s3] [s6] | 2/2 |
| ✓ | 齒顎矯正 Clear-aligner consultation on the appointment form; the director holds Invisalign and French CIDFORMATION aligner certifications. [s6] [s2] | 2/2 |
| ✓ | 口腔外科 Minimally invasive extraction and minimally invasive wisdom-tooth removal, with a French piezosurgery unit on the equipment page. [s4] | 2/2 |
| ✗ | 兒童牙科 Neither the treatments list nor the appointment form offers children’s dentistry. [s4] [s6] | 0/1.5 |
| ? | 急症看診 | 0/1.5 |
| ? | 服務國際病患 | 0/2 |
溝通與服務
4 / 10
聯絡診所、取得答覆與完成預約的容易程度——對國際病患而言尤其重要。
| ✗ | 提供 WhatsApp／LINE The footer has a "Line ID：" label but no ID or add-friend link. [s1] | 0/2 |
| ? | 回覆速度 | 0/1.5 |
| ? | 可用英語溝通 | 0/2.5 |
| ✓ | 可事前諮詢 The appointment-booking form lets patients state their concern from a checklist and be called back to fix an appointment. [s6] | 1.5/1.5 |
| ✓ | 服務說明清楚 A page per treatment explaining the procedure in plain language. [s4] | 1/1 |
| ✓ | 看診時間方便 Published weekly grid with evening sessions 18:15–20:15 Monday to Thursday; no weekend sessions. [s5b] | 1.5/1.5 |
AI 與搜尋能見度
1.5 / 10
患者搜尋時是否找得到這家診所——包括透過 AI 助理搜尋。檢測使用固定的查詢語句："best dentist Taiwan"、"English speaking dentist Taiwan"、"dental implants Taiwan"、"emergency dentist Taiwan"、"Taiwan dental clinic for expats"。
| ✗ | 被提及：best dentist Taiwan Not named in the top answer. [sq1] | 0/1 |
| ✗ | 被提及：English speaking dentist Taiwan Not named in the top answer. [sq2] | 0/1 |
| ✗ | 被提及：dental implants Taiwan Web search 2026-09-06: not among results for "dental implants Kaohsiung" (top results were Kaohsiung VGH International Medical Center, Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, and generic Taiwan implant-cost articles). [sq3] | 0/1 |
| ✗ | 被提及：emergency dentist Taiwan Web search 2026-09-06: not among results for "emergency dentist Kaohsiung" (top results were Big W Dental Clinic, AIT health-provider directory, and Kaohsiung VGH). [sq4] | 0/1 |
| ✗ | 被提及：Taiwan dental clinic for expats Web search 2026-09-06: not among results for "Kaohsiung dental clinic for expats" (top results were Kaohsiung VGH International Medical Center and Big W Dental Clinic). [sq5] | 0/1 |
| ✗ | 網站具備結構化資料 No schema.org JSON-LD in the page source. [s1] | 0/1.5 |
| ✗ | Google 索引品質 the clinic's own domain (aitooth.com.tw) does not appear anywhere in 10 results; only the clinic's own Facebook page, unrelated same-city competitor Facebook pages and unrelated Kaohsiung-institution Wikipedia entries surfaced (web search 2026-09-07) [giq1] | 0/2 |
| ✓ | 各項服務設有專屬頁面 A separate page per treatment (product-7 … product-17). [s4] | 1.5/1.5 |
執照與資格
診所是否公開其開業執照，以及在此執業的牙醫師與他們的牙醫師證書字號。經查證確認未公開者，會記錄為警示標記；尚未查核的資料則標示為未查證，不予扣分。
診所開業執照: 3702031448 — MOHW institution code; facility type general dental clinic, operating status operating, NHI-contracted since 2000-06-29. Checked in the MOHW institution register on 2026-09-04. [reg1] [reg3]
牙醫師與專業證照
| 牙醫師 | 專科 | 證書字號 |
|---|---|---|
| 吳文鑫 [s2] [reg2] | Director; postgraduate implant and periodontics training, University of Michigan, USA; board-certified implant specialist, Taiwan Academy of Implant Dentistry; Master's degree in periodontics and prosthodontics, Kaohsiung Medical University; Master's degree in implant dentistry, Taipei Medical University | 未查證 |
| 林明賢 [s2] [reg2] | Attending dentist; board-certified specialist, Republic of China Academy of Family Dentistry; board-certified specialist, Taipei Academy of Oral Rehabilitation; postgraduate periodontics and implant-treatment training, University of Southern California, USA | 未查證 |
| 郭立儒 [s2] [reg2] | Attending dentist; Department of Dentistry, Taipei Medical University; Graduate Institute of Periodontics and Prosthodontics, Kaohsiung Medical University; Southern Taiwan executive director, Taiwan Academy of Implant Dentistry | 未查證 |
有列出牙醫師姓名；其證書字號尚未與公開來源比對——未查證，不扣分。
警示標記
在我們檢視過的公開來源中，未發現警示標記。
我們無法查證的資料
- 價格透明度: 公開洗牙價格
- 價格透明度: 公開補牙價格
- 價格透明度: 公開牙冠價格
- 價格透明度: 公開植牙價格
- 價格透明度: 公開初診諮詢費用
- 價格透明度: 公開 X 光／影像檢查價格
- 口碑與評論: 診所回覆評論
- 口碑與評論: 無重複出現的客訴
- 醫療設備與服務: 急症看診
- 醫療設備與服務: 服務國際病患
- 溝通與服務: 回覆速度
- 溝通與服務: 可用英語溝通
未查證的項目以 0 分計算，但不會被視為負面的查核結果。如果您能提供其中任何一項的佐證資料，歡迎回報更正。
聯絡資訊
| 網站 | https://www.aitooth.com.tw/ |
|---|---|
| 電話 | +886 7 347 0388 |
| https://www.facebook.com/denttop/ | |
| Google 地圖 | 地圖商家頁面 |
| 地址 | 高雄市左營區華夏路722號1、2樓 (No. 722, Huaxia Rd., Zuoying Dist., Kaohsiung, Taiwan) |
聯絡資訊僅供辨識之用，且可能有所變動；請直接向診所確認。
資料來源
| 編號 | 來源 | 佐證的項目 | 查閱日期 |
|---|---|---|---|
| s1 | https://www.aitooth.com.tw/ | Clinic homepage: contacts, Facebook link, premises photographs, absence of a fee page and of an English version | 2026-09-04 |
| s2 | https://www.aitooth.com.tw/article-team.html | Dentist-team page — three dentists with full credentials | 2026-09-04 |
| s3 | https://www.aitooth.com.tw/book-1.html | Equipment page — 3D CBCT, digital panoramic and cephalometric X-ray, operating-room X-ray, surgical microscope, laser, piezosurgery, NSK implant motor | 2026-09-04 |
| s4 | https://www.aitooth.com.tw/product2.html | Treatment-services page — the seven treatment areas and their individual pages; no prices | 2026-09-04 |
| s5b | https://www.aitooth.com.tw/article-outpatient.html | Clinic-hours page — the weekly session grid with evening sessions and the dentist on duty | 2026-09-04 |
| s6 | https://www.aitooth.com.tw/contact.html | Booking page — the appointment form listing implant, aligner, whitening and denture consultations as bookable items | 2026-09-04 |
| reg1 | https://ma.mohw.gov.tw/Accessibility/BASSearch/MASearchBAS | MOHW medical institution search (Ministry of Health and Welfare medical institution register): institution code, ownership class, facility type, operating status, phone, street address and NHI-contract flag | 2026-09-04 |
| reg2 | https://ma.mohw.gov.tw/Accessibility/DOCSearch/MASearchDOC | MOHW medical personnel search (Ministry of Health and Welfare medical personnel register): confirms that a named person is a currently registered practising dentist and the county of practice. The register publishes no licence number and no person-to-clinic link. | 2026-09-04 |
| reg3 | https://info.nhi.gov.tw/api/iode0000s01/Dataset?rId=A21030000I-D210… | National Health Insurance Administration open dataset (NHI-contracted institutions – clinics; daily refresh, file timestamp 2026-09-04): institution code, name, phone, address, contract start date and contract-end / closure date | 2026-09-04 |
| s5 | https://www.dentco.tw/clinic/3702031448 | Dent&Co ("Dentist's Helper") directory profile: corroborates address and phone and carries 2,455 public patient reviews (existence and third-party review presence only; not a clinic channel) | 2026-09-04 |
| sq1 | search:best dentist Kaohsiung | Canonical visibility query run 2026-09-04 | 2026-09-04 |
| sq2 | search:English speaking dentist Kaohsiung | Canonical visibility query run 2026-09-04 | 2026-09-04 |
| sq3 | search:dental implants Kaohsiung | AI/search visibility scout — canonical query | 2026-09-06 |
| sq4 | search:emergency dentist Kaohsiung | AI/search visibility scout — canonical query | 2026-09-06 |
| sq5 | search:Kaohsiung dental clinic for expats | AI/search visibility scout — canonical query | 2026-09-06 |
| gmp1 | https://www.google.com/maps/place/%E4%B8%8A%E9%BC%8E%E7%89%99%E9%86… | Live Google Maps place page read in a browser: rating, review count, star histogram, review dates, owner replies, listing website, phone, address and pin coordinates | 2026-09-06 |
| giq1 | search:上鼎牙醫診所 高雄 Shangding Dental Clinic Kaohsiung | the clinic's own domain (aitooth.com.tw) does not appear anywhere in 10 results; only the clinic's own Facebook page, unrelated same-city competitor Facebook pages and unrelated Kaohsiung-institution Wikipedia entries surfaced | 2026-09-07 |
| shangding-dental-kaohsiung-deepen | https://www.google.com/maps?cid=6131778742104440042&hl=en | Google listing the clinic's own (Periodontist; No. 722, Huasia Rd, Xinguang Village, Zuoying District, Kaohsiung City, Taiwan 813), read 2026-10-05 in 4 review orders (lowest-rated first, newest first, most relevant first, highest-rated first): 4.4 from 189 reviews (1★ 28 / 2★ 2 / 3★ 0 / 4★ 4 / 5★ 155); 12 distinct reviews read, dated 2021-06-21 to 2026-09-09, 2 with an owner reply. | 2026-10-05 |
| shangding-dental-kaohsiung-tripadvisor | https://www.tripadvisor.com/TypeAheadJson?action=API&details=true&q… | TripAdvisor's own search, read 2026-10-05: 12 suggestions for the clinic's name in its own script with "Kaohsiung" (1 place, 4 attractions, 6 hotels, 1 restaurant), none of them a dental practice in or near Kaohsiung; no suggestions for the clinic's name in its own script; no listing for this clinic | 2026-10-05 |
| shangding-dental-kaohsiung-tripadvisor-2 | https://www.aitooth.com.tw/ | Clinic's website, home page read 2026-10-05: no link to a TripAdvisor page | 2026-10-05 |
| shangding-dental-kaohsiung-deepen-2 | https://www.google.com/maps?cid=6131778742104440042&hl=en | Google listing the clinic's own (Periodontist; No. 722, Huasia Rd, Xinguang Village, Zuoying District, Kaohsiung City, Taiwan 813), read 2026-10-05 in 4 review orders (highest-rated first, lowest-rated first, newest first, most relevant first): 4.4 from 189 reviews (1★ 28 / 2★ 2 / 3★ 0 / 4★ 4 / 5★ 155); 12 distinct reviews read, dated 2021-06-21 to 2026-09-09, 2 with an owner reply. | 2026-10-05 |
變更紀錄
| 日期 | 變更內容 |
|---|---|
| 2026-10-05 | TripAdvisor presence checked on 2026-10-05: no listing found for this clinic. |
| 2026-09-29 | Corrected 2026-09-29: no recurring complaints now unverified: 1–2★ ratings are 29 of 188 and the low reviews themselves were not read; clinic responds to reviews now unverified: only 3 reviews were checked for owner replies. |
| 2026-09-06 | Checked by hand in a browser: the Google Maps place page was opened in a real browser and read for rating, review count, star histogram, review recency, owner replies, complaint and manipulation reading, listing website, phone, address and pin coordinates; the checks that needed a rendering browser were worked through on the clinic own channels. |
| 2026-09-04 | Initial data collection for the Taiwan Dental Transparency & Trust Index: verified against the clinic’s own site, the MOHW institution and personnel registers and the NHI daily open dataset. |
有疑問或需要更正？
對這個頁面有疑問、建議，或需要更正嗎？歡迎與我們聯絡——每一則訊息我們都會讀。經查證的資料更正會比對來源後套用，並留下公開的變更紀錄。